To 3G, or not to 3G, updated
Aug 21st, 2008 by admin
So it’s August, and I still haven’t upgraded to the iPhone 3G. I actually waited in line at my local podunk AT&T store on the first day they were released, but after standing in line for several hours, just a few people had emerged with iPhones and I gave it up. We all know about the issues with activation, and even a month after release, the iPhone itself is still coyly playing hard-to-get. Before I expend a lot of energy trying to get my hands on one, I wanted to compile a list of good reasons to upgrade…or not to upgrade.
I’ve been checking out the software releases as they come along, and this week’s 2.0.2 seems to have fixed most of the initial bugginess. I finally got my 2G iPhone to pull in my Exchange email from work, without an Enterprise data plan (shhhh…don’t tell AT&T), so overall I’m still pretty happy with it. There are a surprising number of possible upgrades the 3G doesn’t have, such as landscape keyboard while in email or texting, Flash support in the browser, file transfer and storage, and frickin’ copy and paste ability. Anywho, here’s the list. I’ve left out the tiny nice-to-have improvements like the smaller charger plug - just thinking of the big stuff here.
Pros:
- Faster data speed. This is less of an issue now that I don’t spend 3 hours a day on the commuter bus, but still — when I do want info, I don’t want to wait for the dialup-reminiscent speed of EDGE.
- Larger capacity. I’ve reached the limit with my 8G and can’t fit all my music and apps on it. I currently have zero room left for any photos, podcasts or videos.
- True GPS. Not sure how much I would use this, but I do use the triangulation-based faux-GPS fairly often.
- Improved call and sound quality, a much-needed upgrade. Louder and clearer are better, especially for someone who went to waaayyy too many extremely loud rock concerts in her impetuous youth.
- Improved headphone jack. The new flush jack means I can use my favorite SkullCandy headphones with it.
- The ability to use the internet while on the phone. I’ve been frustrated and annoyed with the lack of this functionality in the past.
- It would make my teenager really happy, because I’d pass down my 2G iPhone to him.
Cons:
- Price. The iPhone itself is not that expensive on its own because I qualify for an upgrade through AT&T, but the 3G data plan is pricier, and text messages are no longer free. Add in the iPhone plan for my son (he currently has a Blackberry, but no data plan) and it becomes an increase of about $35/month.
- Battery woes. Several of my coworkers have the 3G and complain that they have to keep the 3G service turned off or it inhales battery power. What’s a 3G iPhone without 3G? I could always switch it on when I need it, but Apple really has to get the battery issue under control, especially if they continue with the !#$%^&* non-user-replaceable concept.
- The plastic back. There have been some reports of hairline cracks in the plastic, even right out of the box. The cracks seem to be much more visible on the white models, and Apple is OK about replacing them some of the time, but it’s not good.
- Rumors of a 32GB iPhone for the holidays. These rumors are completely unsubstantiated, and I really don’t need more than about 10 GB total, but still…I like to try to avoid The Curse Of The Early Adopter whenever possible.
